Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

Why did Ellie let Abby escape?

Why did Ellie let Abby escape?

Ellie Thought Of Joel During TLOU 2's Ending

Through that, not only did Ellie realize that this wasn't going to bring back Joel (or honor his memory), but that it would only be contributing to the cycle of violence. Allowing Abby to live in TLOU 2's ending was symbolic of her finally letting go.


Did Ellie get revenge on Abby?

Did Ellie get revenge on Abby?

Eventually, Ellie gets the upper hand, and begins to drown Abby underwater, but another memory of Joel apparently triggers one final act of mercy, and she lets her escape with Lev by boat. Ellie returns to Wyoming to find her farmstead home vacated, aside from her studio of music and paintings.


Why Ellie forgives Abby?

Why Ellie forgives Abby?

Ellie doesn't just casually spare Abby. The whole reason she obsessed over her the whole game is because Abby took away the opportunity to forgive Joel, once she finally did that at the end of the game then she was able to let Abby go.


Does Abby feel guilty about killing Joel?

Does Abby feel guilty about killing Joel?

As we see in Abby's flashbacks to the hospital, her guilt lies in not being able to protect her father and in killing Joel. I think she made herself feel even more terrible by killing Joel, and the only thing she truly got closure from was by saving Yara and Lev.


Why did Ellie hate Joel?

Why did Ellie hate Joel?

It is revealed that Ellie's distrust of Joel's lie at the end of The Last of Us led to her discovering the truth. Due to Joel taking Ellie's choice of making a cure away from her, Ellie begins to resent Joel, only worsened by her survivor's guilt.


Did Abby break Ellie's arm?

Did Abby break Ellie's arm?

Ellie flees, hiding in the shadows where she draws her bow and arrow and plants mines and tosses Molotov cocktails at Abby. However, Abby sneaks up on Ellie once more, throws her to the floor, breaks her arm and begins beating her to death.


Who is the bad guy Ellie or Abby?

Who is the bad guy Ellie or Abby?

Abby becomes Ellie's worst enemy in The Last of Us Part 2, but after players spend time with her, they realize that her story is a complex one.


Why did Ellie fight Abby again?

Why did Ellie fight Abby again?

Her guilt is likely exacerbated by more recent events as well – Jesse was killed, Tommy lost an eye, and Ellie even admitted to Abby that she blames herself for Joel killing Abby's father. For Ellie, there was only one way to avenge Joel: killing Abby.


Why is Abby so buff?

Why is Abby so buff?

The choice to make Abby bulkier isn't arbitrary, either; she strengthens herself physically after her father is murdered so she can capably go out and exact her revenge in the way she deems appropriate, which turns out to be beating his murderer to death with a golf club.


Does Ellie get happy ending?

Does Ellie get happy ending?

First, there's the satisfying ending of vengeance as Ellie puts Abby down, which is taken from us when Ellie surrenders and allows Abby and Lev to leave. Then there's the happy ending of Ellie's peaceful future she's finally ready to accept, which is taken from us when she returns home to find Dina and J.J. have left.


Why is Joel killed in Last of Us 2?

Why is Joel killed in Last of Us 2?

In the video game's sequel, “The Last of Us Part II,” Joel is shockingly murdered in the first act of the game by Abby, the daughter of the Firefly surgeon Joel killed in order to let Ellie live. Joel's death sets Ellie up on a mission of revenge against Abby.


Who is good Abby or Ellie?

Who is good Abby or Ellie?

No preference here. They are both a good time. for me, it was less about their campaigns and more about the sections they had. like, I really liked the part where Ellie first comes across the Seraphites.


Did Ellie feel bad for killing Mel?

Did Ellie feel bad for killing Mel?

Ellie Kills Mel

Ellie tries to interrogate them but ends up killing them both. After murdering them, Ellie realizes that Mel is pregnant. Not only does Ellie feel guilty for taking an unborn baby's life, but she also realizes she is putting her girlfriend, Dina (who is also pregnant), in harm's way.


Why do people hate Abby from The Last of Us Part 2?

Why do people hate Abby from The Last of Us Part 2?

I hate Abby.” Reprehensibly, some fans have even gone so far as to threaten the life of Abby voice actor, Laura Bailey. Abby has attracted resentment largely because she brutally kills Joel, the main character of The Last of Us, at the very beginning of the game.


What does Joel get killed with?

What does Joel get killed with?

In an earlier version of the scene, Abby stabbed Joel in the back and twisted the knife to paralyze him; however, as knives are more closely associated with Ellie, the team replaced it with a golf club, partly inspired by an incident in Druckmann's youth.


Does Joel actually love Ellie?

Does Joel actually love Ellie?

Having finally grown to love Ellie like a daughter, though, Joel isn't about to let that happen. He shoots his way through the hospital to rescue her, killing everyone in his path and then lying to Ellie about what really happened by telling her that raiders attacked the hospital.


Did Joel fall in love with Ellie?

Did Joel fall in love with Ellie?

The road leading to the climax of HBO's The Last of Us has been built around the relationship formed by Ellie (Bella Ramsey) and Joel (Pedro Pascal). Initially antagonistic, it soon becomes a relationship of convenience, necessity, and eventually, love.


Did Ellie still love Joel?

Did Ellie still love Joel?

And because Joel was like a father to Ellie, their bond fuels Ellie's quest for revenge. However, Ellie does have some relief, knowing that in their final conversation, she told Joel she might be able to forgive him. She then knows Joel died knowing that she still loves him .


How old is Ellie when she fights Abby?

How old is Ellie when she fights Abby?

Ellie reappeared as the playable character in the downloadable content prequel The Last of Us: Left Behind, in which she spends time with her friend Riley. In The Last of Us Part II (2020), players control a 19-year-old Ellie as she seeks revenge on Abby.


Does Abby get hanged?

Does Abby get hanged?

The Seraphites hang Abby. Abby awakens later that night as a group of Seraphites, led by Emily, prepare to ritually kill her in their prophet's name. Abby is hung by the neck, with a bucket for support so she will not suffocate before she can be disemboweled.


How much older than Ellie is Abby?

How much older than Ellie is Abby?

Ellie and Abby are representative of a new generation

Despite her tough, muscular physique and Laura Bailey's deep voice, it's canon that Abby is roughly around the same age as Ellie, who is 19 years old when the events of "Part II" first begin to unfold.


Is Joel evil in the last of us?

Is Joel evil in the last of us?

This is not to say Joel is evil or vindictive. He's shown to be utterly ruthless over the course of The Last of Us, but it's also clear he's acting out of necessity. Joel takes no pleasure in the killing and destruction; he is just doing what it takes to survive and protect Ellie.


Does Ellie turn evil?

Does Ellie turn evil?

Despite being an anti-hero, she becomes more villainous in the sequel where she is blinded by revenge and uses extreme methods of violence against her enemies, leading to her accidentally killing a pregnant woman in self-defense and threatening to kill Lev, a child.


Does Ellie forgive Joel?

Does Ellie forgive Joel?

Here's the long and short of it: Joel was killed before Ellie could forgive him. Her guilt over failing to repair her relationship with the only father figure in her life fuelled her need for revenge, but by not killing Abby, she could forgive Joel through her.


Is Joel still alive?

Is Joel still alive?

Time to rip off the band-aid: Joel is killed off early in The Last of Us Part II video game. The scene is a particularly brutal one and is the catalyst for the rest of Ellie's actions throughout the rest of the game.


How did Ellie lose her fingers?

How did Ellie lose her fingers?

How the hell could Abby bite off Ellie's fingers?! Yes, it is possible. Firstly, Abby was fighting for her life, therefore adrenaline enhanced her. Second, it is rather easy to bite one's fingers off so long as they bite in between the joints where bone is brittle and thin compared to the rest.


Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

Much of the controversy surrounding The Last of Us Part II have to do with the death of Joel, which occurs incredibly early in the game.


Why is Abby so masculine?

Why is Abby so masculine?

It's not that shes just buff, because there are plenty of feminine hard body woman around. They intentionally made Abby look MASCULINE. My theory is she was meant to be a male, but as Drunkman said, someone would often say "what if it was a woman, would it change anything?" when they were developing the game.


Why does Abby look so manly?

Why does Abby look so manly?

However, the reason that Abby is so muscular is because the WLF has trained her for years, and fans will even see large gyms at the beginning of Abby's segment of the game. The reason that Abby has gotten so muscular over the years is because the WLF has both large farms and full gyms for training.


Is Abby unrealistic?

Is Abby unrealistic?

Being big and scary is crucial to Abby's character, no matter how much gamers say it's 'unrealistic'. There was huge backlash to Abby Anderson's character design in The Last of Us Part 2 because she was considered by many gamers to be 'too buff' for a woman.


Why did Ellie let Abby live?

Why did Ellie let Abby live?

Allowing Abby to live in TLOU 2's ending was symbolic of her finally letting go. After watching her adopt a colder, more brutal mentality after Joel's death, the decision to spare her archenemy's life can initially seem senseless and out of the blue.


Who is Ellie in love with?

Who is Ellie in love with?

In Left Behind she kissed Riley, and the creator confirmed they had a romantic relationship, and that Ellie was a lesbian. The actresses were even working on the fact that they were in love.


How old is Ellie at the end?

How old is Ellie at the end?

The bulk of Part 2 is set in 2038, with Ellie 19 years old and her relationship with Joel having strained considerably after she learned what he did to the Fireflies in Salt Lake City five years prior.


Did Abby regret killing Joel?

Did Abby regret killing Joel?

While Abby does not presumably regret killing Joel, it becomes increasingly clear to her by now that it did nothing for her except distance her from Owen and Mel — also unaware at this point about Ellie killing her other friends.


Did Ellie know Joel lied?

Did Ellie know Joel lied?

While the creators offer several different interpretations of what Ellie is actually thinking at the end of The Last of Us' finale, both agree and make clear that she definitely knows he's lying to her.


Does Joel ever tell Ellie the truth?

Does Joel ever tell Ellie the truth?

Ellie will eventually learn the truth about what happened at the hospital, and that moment is not too far away. Early in the original The Last of Us Part II video game, Joel reveals that he lied to Ellie - something that she does not handle well.


Is Ellie or Abby the villain?

Is Ellie or Abby the villain?

Abigail "Abby" Anderson is one of the two main protagonists (alongside Ellie Williams) of Naughty Dog's 2020 video game The Last of Us Part II, serving as the main antagonist of Ellie's storyline and the main protagonist of her own storyline.


Why Ellie forgives Abby?

Why Ellie forgives Abby?

Ellie doesn't just casually spare Abby. The whole reason she obsessed over her the whole game is because Abby took away the opportunity to forgive Joel, once she finally did that at the end of the game then she was able to let Abby go.


Is Ellie's mom the original Ellie?

Is Ellie's mom the original Ellie?

'The Last of Us': HBO Reveals First Look at Ashley Johnson as Ellie's Mom Anna - IMDb. HBO has released a first-look image of Ashley Johnson, the original voice actor of Ellie in The Last of Us video game, as Anna, Ellie's (Bella Ramsey) mother.


Would killing Ellie have made a cure?

Would killing Ellie have made a cure?

However, long-time fans know that the cure was not guaranteed in the game. Ellie still gave the doctors their best hope for creating a cure or vaccine, but it was just as likely that Ellie's death would be for nothing. It's easy to see why HBO chose this route.


Does Ellie get happy ending?

Does Ellie get happy ending?

First, there's the satisfying ending of vengeance as Ellie puts Abby down, which is taken from us when Ellie surrenders and allows Abby and Lev to leave. Then there's the happy ending of Ellie's peaceful future she's finally ready to accept, which is taken from us when she returns home to find Dina and J.J. have left.


Why is Ellie quiet after killing David?

Why is Ellie quiet after killing David?

Considering his violent death, his actions left a mark on Ellie, making her distant and quiet towards Joel yet more determined to reach the Fireflies.


Did Owen cheat with Abby?

Did Owen cheat with Abby?

This culminated in him having an affair with Abby, which only worsened the strained relationship between the pair.


Why is Abby so buff?

Why is Abby so buff?

The choice to make Abby bulkier isn't arbitrary, either; she strengthens herself physically after her father is murdered so she can capably go out and exact her revenge in the way she deems appropriate, which turns out to be beating his murderer to death with a golf club.


Why does Abby kills Joel?

Why does Abby kills Joel?

Abby kills Joel in revenge, which happens in the first few hours of The Last of Us Part II. Given this knowledge, it can be assumed that Joel's death will potentially come in the season premiere of The Last of Us season 2, if not the second episode at the latest.


Why did Ellie hate Joel?

Why did Ellie hate Joel?

It is revealed that Ellie's distrust of Joel's lie at the end of The Last of Us led to her discovering the truth. Due to Joel taking Ellie's choice of making a cure away from her, Ellie begins to resent Joel, only worsened by her survivor's guilt.


Did Joel love Ellie as much as Sarah?

Did Joel love Ellie as much as Sarah?

He even affectionately calls Ellie "baby girl", which is the same endearment he used for Sarah, suggesting that Joel views his relationship with Ellie as similar to what he had with Sarah.


Was Joel in love with Tess?

Was Joel in love with Tess?

Joel and Tess' relationship in Naughty Dog's The Last of Us has always been uncertain. It was clear in the 2013 game that they cared enough for each other to form a healthy partnership, but subtle quips also implied they were romantically involved.


Did Joel treat Ellie like a daughter?

Did Joel treat Ellie like a daughter?

He genuinely began to see her as his daughter, and for the same reason, kept her out of harm's way. Joel's affection for Ellie was born out of grief, and parental loss. He gradually began to accept her as his own and that's why he called her by the same term of endearment, "baby girl," that he'd use on Sarah.


Does Joel ever warm up to Ellie?

Does Joel ever warm up to Ellie?

Joel is initially surly and short towards Ellie, though he begins to warm up to her as their journey continues. This is compounded when Joel, having initially asked Tommy to carry on in his place after meeting up with him at Tommy's settlement in Jackson, changes his mind and carries on as planned.


How old is Ellie after Joel dies?

How old is Ellie after Joel dies?

Ellie reappeared as the playable character in the downloadable content prequel The Last of Us: Left Behind, in which she spends time with her friend Riley. In The Last of Us Part II (2020), players control a 19-year-old Ellie as she seeks revenge on Abby.


Who is Ellie with after Joel dies?

Who is Ellie with after Joel dies?

Getting back to the story, several months pass after Ellie and Abby's encounter. Ellie and Dina are living on an isolated farm taking care of Dina's baby.


How much older is Abby then Ellie?

How much older is Abby then Ellie?

This means when her father Jerry Anderson -- the surgeon who would've operated on and killed Ellie -- was murdered by Joel in the Salt Lake City hospital in 2034, she was in her mid-teens. By this logic, Abby is a few years older than Ellie, who is 19 in the main events of The Last of Us Part II.


How tall is Ellie at 14?

How tall is Ellie at 14?

Ellie's height in TLOU part 2 is 5'5"(166cm) at 19 years old and 5'3"(160cm) at 14/15 years old (museum flashback).


Why does Ellie spare Abby reddit?

Why does Ellie spare Abby reddit?

Did Ellie ever forgive Joel?


Does Abby regret killing Joel in The Last of Us 2?

Does Abby regret killing Joel in The Last of Us 2?

Did Abby break Ellie's arm?


What did Ellie do to Abby?

What did Ellie do to Abby?

Ellie lets Abby go because she see's Lev and realizes that they are a reflection of her and Joel. She understands in the moment that Joel wouldn't want this life for her. Maybe hunter Joel would seek revenge. But older Joel wouldn't.


Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

Why is The Last of Us Part 2 so controversial?

While Abby does not presumably regret killing Joel, it becomes increasingly clear to her by now that it did nothing for her except distance her from Owen and Mel — also unaware at this point about Ellie killing her other friends.


1